Here are the best "similarity scores" from baseball-reference.com for Andre Dawson.

1. Billy Williams (886) *
2. Tony Perez (881) *
3. Dave Parker (865)
4. Al Kaline (858) *
5. Harold Baines (856)
6. Luis Gonzalez (842)
7. Ernie Banks (834) *
8. Dwight Evans (834)
9. Dave Winfield (824) *
10. Gary Sheffield (818)
* - Signifies Hall of Famer

5 HOF'ers, 4 who are not in and 1 still active.