BYOF, just checked their DMB "cards"

Ignoring usage rules/issues, my OF is as follows

vs RHP: Dukes (278/397/436) AVG in LF, Bruce (286/340/529) and AVG in CF and Dejesus (310/384/491) VG in RF. The difference between Burrell (.351oba and 492 slg vs rhp) and Bruce is small enough that DEF wins the day.
vs LHP" Burrell in LF, Soriano in RF and either dejesus or dukes in CF. with dejesus over dukes, you're giving up about 30 points in OBA but you're gaining a rank in Defense, so it might be a wash, but I'd go with the D if you can afford to based on the rest of your lineup.