Quote:
What if I put Albert Pujols in RF for the 2006 season in which he was rated at only 1B. How bad would he be?...Will his performance be worse than a PR fielder?

I would expect (especially since he's rated only at 1B) that his performance would be worse than a PR rightfielder. It makes sense to me in these instances to add a fielding rating for the player that takes into consideration his previous experience playing the position, how much older he is than when he last played the position and how his health/fitness/body type has changed since then. My biggest concern with Pujols specifically would be the foot problems he's battled the last couple of years...how would that effect his ability to play in the outfield?